Charlotte Tilbury Refillable Eyebrow Pencil at Sephora Jump to Review Best Overall, Runner-Up: Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Definer at Amazon Jump to Review Best Budget: e.l.f. Brow $28 at Ulta Beauty Credit: Courtesy Image This two-in-one eyebrow pencil is a game changer. On one end, there's a fine-tip pencil that helps you mimic the appearance of your natural brow Shop Now $31 Kimiko's brow pencils have been a go-to of Black's for years. "The tip is a superfine, extremely precise point that makes it easy to create the illusion of realistic brow hairs," Jan. 23, 2022. The Zoe Report/Amazon. For stay-all-day brows that will endure through workouts, rain showers, and sweaty summer days, you're going to need to upgrade your brow pencil. In short, the best long-lasting brow pencils are waterproof or water-resistant, though you can also keep an eye out for terms like "smudge proof" and The best eyebrow pencils for 2023 are: Best overall - BBB ultra thin brow definer 2.0: £19, Bbb-london.com. Best for natural brows - MAC eyebrow styler: £18.50, Maccosmetics.com. Best value Feature Image by Sephora Everyone says diamonds are a girl's best friend, but what about perfectly-sculpted brows? We'd bet exemplary arches are right up there with jewels and gems. After all, they can totally make or break your look. To ensure your eyebrows look their very best, check out our favorite smudge-proof brow pencils below. Most makeup artists recommend having an eyebrow pencil in your makeup bag for days when you're in a hurry and need a quick brow fix. Eyebrow pencils are excellent tools for refining the shape of the brows and filling in sparse areas. We carefully vet eyebrow pencils for both of these capabilities. Eyebrow pencils are great for drawing a specific brow shape or sketching in individual "hairs" onto sparse brows. Eyebrow gels help tame and shape brow hairs, and come in versions that BJoP.